American Hotel

  • Hotel in Sag Harbor
The American Hotel

Get the lobster BLT for lunch!

This red-brick Victorian hasn’t changed much since 1846. And that’s just how guests like it, with its faded elegance, backgammon tables in the lobby, and a bartender who will soon know your name.

Map

Reviews

  • Steve Haweeli

    Get the lobster BLT for lunch!

  • Pia Fouilloux

    The macadamia tart it's like a little bit of heaven! 👌

  • allie white

    This place reeks of wealth. Super iconic, classy and old fashioned. Billy Joel is standing next to me.

  • Travel + Leisure

    This red-brick Victorian hasn’t changed much since 1846. And that’s just how guests like it, with its faded elegance, backgammon tables in the lobby, and a bartender who will soon know your name.

  • Robert S

    Best wine list, late night bar, for a more mature crowd. Fun brunch on patio.

  • Lisette P

    Possibly the best Croque Madame I've ever had.

  • Patrick Mclaughlin

    Take you grandparents!

  • The Corcoran Group

    Sit at the bar with Vinnie or Paul, grab a backgammon table in the front room, dine outside and watch the crowds, or host an intimate party in one of the private rooms.

  • Crystal Gardner

    Some times people become mayor when they don't deserve to

  • Crystal Gardner

    Some people check in when they aren't even there yet

  • David Taylor

    Lovely terrace to go with lovely food! Watch the cars and people as you enjoy a sandwich and a glass of rose.

  • Savannah Petrick

    grab a drink before dinner

  • Alonso Carral

    the scallop risotto is amazing

  • Daniel Powell

    More traditional, food was great but people come for the wine list

  • Gaëlle Ma Tata

    Very tasty lobster sandwich in a nice and luxus atmosphere

  • Linda Song

    Let's talk banana fosters. Wow. It looks heavy, but it's not a stomach killer at all. Just delicious caramelly goodness.

  • Linda Song

    You don't expect it, but their coffee is absolutely delicious. I had to stop myself from pouring more! Hahaha would have been up all night!

  • Linda Song

    It's no Maryland crab cake and the 'burger' in the title is misleading, but their crab cake burger (rather, sandwich) is really good!

  • Joel

    Classic old style Americana , French cuisine from 20 years ago but really good and really nice wine list.

  • Ernie Huber

    Very cool but expensive. It's like you stepped back in time.

Hotel in Sag Harbor

American Hotel

49 Main St, Sag Harbor

Baron's Cove

31 Water St., Sag Harbor

Popular Categories